Fuck Yeah Fluid Dynamics

Fluids Round-up - 25 May 2013

Sat, 25 May 2013 13:00:40 -0500

Sometimes I come across cool links and stories about fluid dynamics that don’t quite fit into a typical FYFD post, but I’d like to start sharing those semi-regularly with round-up posts. Here’s some fun stuff I’ve seen lately:

We’ve talked before about penguins and fluid dynamics, but this IOP talk from Helen Czerski is a great take on how they use fluids to escape predators.
Over at FlowViz, Richard has a great video demonstrating deep versus shallow water waves side-by-side.
io9 shows off the vibrational modes of mercury as well as explaining why birds can be good at flying or swimming but not both.
Giant paint explosions (specifically here) may be fun to watch but the dangers are not for squeamish viewers.
Dylan G sent us this 512K real-time fluid particle simulation that’s a fun distraction.
xckd’s Randall Munroe answers all kinds of physics questions at his What If? blog, but occasionally there are some fluids ones. Two of my favorites consider a hypersonic steak and what happens if the glass is literally half full.
Finally, for the cyclists and triathletes among you, the recent news that bicycle manufacturer Specialized has built its own wind tunnel has generated lots of discussion of aerodynamics in sport. Mark Cote (@MITAeroBike) and Chris Yu (@chrisyuinc) of Specialized’s aero R&D have been answering questions on Slowtwitch, Twitter, and in live chats.

And, yes, that last Specialized video chat includes an FYFD shout-out about 49 minutes in. :)

(Photo credit: Specialized)

During a solar flare, magnetic field lines on the sun are often...

Fri, 24 May 2013 10:00:30 -0500

During a solar flare, magnetic field lines on the sun are often visible due to the flow of plasma—charged particles—along the lines. According to theory, these magnetic lines should remain intact, but they are sometimes observed breaking and reconnecting with other lines. An interdisciplinary team of researchers suggests that turbulence may be the missing link. In their magnetohydrodynamic simulation, they found that the presence of chaotic turbulent motions made the magnetic line motion entirely unpredictable, whereas laminar flows behaved according to conventional flux-freezing theory. (Photo credit: NASA SDO; Research credit: G. Eyink et al.; via SpaceRef; submitted by jshoer)

A falling column of liquid, like the water from your faucet,...

Thu, 23 May 2013 10:00:28 -0500

A falling column of liquid, like the water from your faucet, will tend to break up into a series of droplets due to the Plateau-Rayleigh instability. This instability is driven by surface tension. Small variations in the radius of the column occur naturally. Where the radius shrinks, the pressure due to surface tension increases, causing liquid to flow away, which shrinks the column’s radius even further. Eventually the column pinches off and breaks into droplets. What’s especially neat is that the size of the final droplets can be predicted based on the column’s initial radius and the wavelength of its disturbances. (Video credit: BYU Splash Lab)

There’s something wonderfully serene about watching water...

Wed, 22 May 2013 10:00:17 -0500

There’s something wonderfully serene about watching water droplets skate their way across the surface of a pool. Here the pool of water is being vibrated at a frequency just below the Faraday instability - meaning that no standing waves form on the surface. Instead, the bounce is just enough to create a thin layer of air between the droplet and the pool to prevent coalescence. With each bounce, gravity’s effect on the water tries to drain the air away, but each rebound lets more air rush in to hold the droplet up. Eventually, gravity wins and the droplets coalesce into the pool. In high-speed that process is mesmerizing, too. (Video credit: K. Welch)

Hills and other topology can have interesting and complex...

Tue, 21 May 2013 10:00:29 -0500

Hills and other topology can have interesting and complex effects on a flowfield. With the FAITH experiment, NASA has been investigating an axisymmetric model hill using a combination of experimental methods. The video above shows flow visualization over the hill in a water channel using dye injection both upstream and downstream of the model. They’ve also done wind tunnel tests with oil-flow visualization, particle-image velocimetry, pressure sensitive paint and other measurement techniques. There are nice photos of some of these by Rob Bulmahn. By combining qualitative and quantitative flow measurement techniques, the researchers are able to capture many different aspects of the flow, which can then be shared and compared with other groups’ works. (Video credit: NASA Ames Research Center)

The world’s most powerful artificial tornado is part of...

Mon, 20 May 2013 10:00:41 -0500

The world’s most powerful artificial tornado is part of the Mercedes-Benz Museum in Stuttgart, Germany. Though popular enough with visitors that the staff will bring out smoke generators to make it visible, the tornado was not built as an attraction - It’s actually part of the building’s fire protection system. The modern open design of the museum meant that conventional smoke removal systems were inadequate. Instead vorticity is generated in the central lobby with 144 wall-mounted jets. The angular velocity created by the jets is strongest at the middle, in the vortex core, due to conservation of angular momentum - exactly the way a spinning ice skater speeds up by pulling his arms in. The core of the vortex is a low pressure area, which draws outside air toward it - this is how the tornado pulls in smoke when there is a fire. The fan on the ceiling provides the pressure draw necessary for the smoke to be pulled up and out of the building at a supposed rate of 4 tons per minute. See the tornado in action here. (Photo credit: Mercedes-Benz Passion; submitted by Ivan)

Imagine a thin layer of viscous liquid sandwiched between two...

Fri, 17 May 2013 10:00:14 -0500

Imagine a thin layer of viscous liquid sandwiched between two horizontal glass plates. Then pull those plates apart at a constant velocity. What you see in the image above is the shape the viscous fluid takes for different speeds, with velocity increasing from left to right and from top to bottom. For lower velocities, the fluid forms tree-like fingers as air comes in from the edges. At higher velocities, though, there’s a transition from the finger-like pattern to a cell-like one. The cells are actually caused by cavitation within the fluid. When the plates are pulled apart fast enough, the local low pressure in the fluid causes cavitation bubbles to form just before the force required to remove the plate reaches its peak. (Photo credit: S. Poivet et al.)

The electrowetting effect can change the shape of a liquid...

Thu, 16 May 2013 10:00:21 -0500

The electrowetting effect can change the shape of a liquid droplet on a surface by applying a voltage across the surface and droplet. Surface tension is a kind of measure of the energy required to maintain a certain drop shape, and that energy can be both chemical and electrical. In the video above, the droplet maintains a small contact area naturally (with no voltage). It expands and flattens under an electrical charge. Varying the voltage will change the degree to which the droplet flattens, but only to a point. Electrowetting is used to control variable lenses and some types of electronic displays. The technology may be used to replace current generation LCDs. (Video credit: V. Arya/Duke University)

Reader juleztalks writes: I’ve just entered an amateur...

Wed, 15 May 2013 10:00:39 -0500

Reader juleztalks writes:

I’ve just entered an amateur triathlon, and there’s a whole load of rules about not “drafting” in the cycle stage (basically, not sitting in other cyclists’ slipstream). However, there are no such rules for the swim or run stage; I thought the effects would be the same from drafting other swimmers and runners. Any ideas?

As in many endurance sports, it’s all a question of energy savings from drag reduction. Drag on an object, like a triathlete, is roughly proportional to fluid density (air for cycling or running, water for swimming), frontal area, and the velocity squared. Because drag increases more drastically for an increase in velocity, it makes sense one would worry most about drag when one’s velocity is highest - on the bike.

Drafting has major benefits in cycling and can reduce drag on a rider by 25-40%. Aerodynamic drag accounts for 70% or more of a cyclist’s energy expenditure, so that reduction can really add up. The energy saved by drafting during cycling can even increase a triathlete’s speed during a subsequent running leg. So it makes sense for a sport’s governing body to be concerned with it.

That said, there’s plenty of room for drag reduction in swimming as well. Even though the velocities are much lower, water’s density is 1,000 times higher than air’s, generating plenty of drag for an athlete to overcome. For swimmers at maximum speed, drafting can reduce drag by 13-26%, depending on relative positioning. Such drafting has been found to increase stroke length and may (or may not) improve subsequent cycling performance.

Although a similar reduction in drag is possible by drafting when running, drag on a runner only accounts for about 8% of his/her energy expenditure so such savings would matters very little next to the swimming and cycling legs. There could be some psychological benefits, though, in terms of pacing oneself. (Photo credit: Optum Pro Cycling p/b Kelly Benefit Strategies)

This gorgeous visualization shows the flow behind a flapping...

Tue, 14 May 2013 10:00:30 -0500

This gorgeous visualization shows the flow behind a flapping foil. Flow in the water tunnel is from right to left, with dye introduced to show streamlines. A flapping foil is a good base model for most flapping flight as well as finned swimming - anything that oscillates to create thrust. As the foil flaps, vorticity is generated and shed along the trailing edge, creating a regularly patterned wake of trailing vortices. (Video credit: R. Godoy-Diana)

When a drop falls from a moderate height into a shallow pool,...

Mon, 13 May 2013 10:00:14 -0500

When a drop falls from a moderate height into a shallow pool, its impact creates a complicated pattern. The photo above is a composite image showing a top-down view 100 ms after such an impact. On the left side, the flow is visualized using dye whereas the right shows a schlieren photograph, in which contrast indicates variations in density. Both methods show the same general structure - an inner vortex ring generated at the edge of the impact crater and formed mostly of drop fluid and an outer vortex ring, consisting primarily of pool fluid, formed by the spreading wave. Both regions show signs of instability and breakdown. (Photo credit: A. Wilkens et al.)

Owls are nearly silent hunters, able to swoop down on their prey...

Fri, 10 May 2013 10:00:43 -0500

Owls are nearly silent hunters, able to swoop down on their prey without the rush of air over their wings giving away their approach, thanks to several key features of their feathers. The trailing edge of their feathers—or any lifting body, like an airplane wing—are a particular source of acoustic noise due to the interaction of turbulence near the surface with the edge. Since owls are especially good at eliminating self-produced noise in a frequency range that overlaps human hearing, investigators want to learn what works for owls and apply to it aircraft. A recent theoretical analysis uses a simplified model of the feather as a porous, elastic plate. The researchers found that the combination of porosity with the elasticity of the trailing edge significantly reduced noise relative to a rigid edge. (Photo credit: N. Jewell; research credit: J. Jaworski and N. Peake)

In applications like drug delivery, it’s often desirable...

Thu, 09 May 2013 10:00:19 -0500

In applications like drug delivery, it’s often desirable to encapsulate one or more liquid droplets in an additional immiscible fluid. These drops-within-drops, called double emulsions, are typically a multi-step process, created from the innermost drop outward. In this new microfluidic technique, though, researchers are able to create multi-component emulsions in a single step. A double-bored capillary tube creates the two inner droplets (both water, dyed different colors) while oil flows down the outside of the injection tube to encapsulate the droplets. The multi-component double emulsions then flow as one to the right in the outer carrier fluid. The spacing of the capillary tubes is critical to prevent the inner droplets from coalescing with one another. (Video credit: L. L. A. Adams et al.)

Soap films are a handy way to create nearly two-dimensional flow...

Wed, 08 May 2013 10:00:28 -0500

Soap films are a handy way to create nearly two-dimensional flow fields. Previously we’ve seen them used to show wake structures of pitching foils, flapping flags, and multiple bodies. In this video, we see the dynamics of a pendulum in a soap film. Initially its length is quite long, and the ring end of the pendulum bobs side-to-side in a figure-8 motion. There are two rotational effects here: one is the standard oscillation of a pendulum about its pivot, the other is the rotation of the pendulum’s ring about its attachment point. Interestingly, they have the same frequency. The major destabilizing force for the pendulum is the periodic shedding of vortices we see off the ring. By shortening the pendulum length, the pendulum’s behavior shifts; first it loses the stationary node in its string. Eventually, the string becomes so short that the pendulum no longer oscillates. (Video credit: M. Bandi et al.)

Ferrofluids are known for their fascinating behaviors when...

Tue, 07 May 2013 10:00:20 -0500

Ferrofluids are known for their fascinating behaviors when subjected to magnetic fields, especially for the distinctive peaks they can form. In this video, we see a very thin ferrofluid drop on a pre-wetted surface just as a uniform perpendicular magnetic field is applied. Immediately the droplet breaks up into tiny isolated peaks that migrate out to the circumference. The interface breaks down from center, where the drop height is largest, and moves outward. Simultaneously, the diffusion of ferrofluid from the circumferential droplets into the surrounding fluid lowers the magnetization of those droplets, making it more difficult for them to repel their neighbors. As a result, they drift outward more slowly and get caught by the faster-moving droplets from within. (Video credit: C. Chen)

When working at the microscale, engineering structures like...

Mon, 06 May 2013 10:00:39 -0500

When working at the microscale, engineering structures like those used for drug delivery systems requires ingenuity. Since it isn’t possible to manipulate particles manually, researchers harness physical effects to do the work for them. Here a droplet filled with millions of polystyrene microparticles sits on a hydrophobic surface, which helps keep the drop’s spherical shape. As the drop evaporates, surface tension and internal flow in the drop help the microparticles self-assemble into a microscopic soccer-ball-like shape. (Video credit: A. Marin et al.; submission by A. Marin)

For a little Friday fun, enjoy this timelapse of magnetic putty...

Fri, 03 May 2013 10:00:22 -0500

For a little Friday fun, enjoy this timelapse of magnetic putty consuming magnets. Really this is a bit of slow-motion magnetohydrodynamics. The magnet’s field exerts a force on the iron-containing putty, which, because it is a fluid, cannot resist deformation under a force. As a result, the putty will flow around the magnet, eventually coming to a stop once it reaches equilibrium, with its iron equally distributed around the magnet. Assuming the putty is homogeneously ferrous (i.e. the iron is mixed equally in the putty), that means the putty will stop moving when the magnet is at its center of mass. (Video credit: J. Shanks; submitted by Neil K.)

So I just read your post about vortices, and now I'm wondering if we could build structures similar to the Corryvreckan and put turbines in them for energy production? Would it be any more efficient than hydroelectric dams? Are you the right person to ask?

Thu, 02 May 2013 17:14:00 -0500

I can’t give you numbers off the top of my head, but I suspect that your typical hydroelectric dam will be more reliable if not more efficient. The trouble with things like the Corryvreckan, aside from the randomness of where the vortices pop up, is that they aren’t there every single day the way, say, Niagara Falls is.

That said, there is on-going work to effectively harness ocean waves for power, with ideas like buoy generators or sea snake generators. As with most concepts one of the difficulties in implementation is determining a safe and efficient manner to transmit the electricity generated from these offshore sites (we’re generally talking miles from shore) to where it’s needed. This problem is often similarly faced by solar and wind energy producers. There are already wave farms in place around the world, though, and it’s a promising field of renewable energy. (Photo credit: Wikimedia)

Literature is full of descriptions of monstrous whirlpools like...

Thu, 02 May 2013 10:00:29 -0500

Between Scylla and Charybdis. By Manipula

Whirlpool in the Naruto Strait, Japan, from the Tokushima Gov't

Saltstraumen near Bodo, Norway, courtesy of Wikimedia

A Corryvreckan whirlpool by Walter Baxter

Literature is full of descriptions of monstrous whirlpools like Charybdis, which threatens Homer’s Odysseus. While it’s not unusual to see a small free vortex in bodies of water, most people would chalk boat-swallowing maelstroms up to literary device. But it turns out that, while there may not be permanent Hollywood-style whirlpools, there are several places in the world where the local tides, currents, and topology combine to produce turbulence, dangerously vortical waters, and even standing vortices on a regular basis.

One example is the Corryvreckan, between the islands of Jura and Scarba off Scotland. In this narrow strait, Atlantic currents are funneled down a deep hole and then thrust upward by a pinnacle of rock that rises some 170 m to only 30 m below the surface. The swift waters and unusual topology produce strong turbulence near the surface and whirlpools pop up throughout the strait. Other “permanent” maelstroms, such as those in Norway and Japan, arise from tidal interactions with similar structures rising from the sea floor.

For more, check out this Smithsonian article, Gjevik et al., Moe et al., and the videos linked above! (Photo credits: Manipula, Tokushima Gov’t, Wikimedia, and W. Baxter; requested by @kb8s)

In experiments, it can be difficult to track individual fluid...

Wed, 01 May 2013 10:00:24 -0500

In experiments, it can be difficult to track individual fluid structures as they flow downstream. Here researchers capture this spatial development by towing a 5-meter flat plate past a stationary camera while visualizing the boundary layer - the area close to the plate. The result is that we see turbulent eddies evolving as they advect downstream. Despite the complicated and seemingly chaotic flow field, the eye is able to pick out patterns and structure, like the merging of vortices that lifts eddies up into turbulent bulges and the entrainment of freestream fluid into the boundary layer as the eddies turn over or collapse. It is also a great demonstration of how the Reynolds number relates to the separation of scales in a turbulent flow. Notice how much richer the variety of length-scale is for the higher Reynolds number case and how thoroughly this mixes the boundary layer. (Video credit: J. H. Lee et al.)